Karpov’s Letter: Desperate Tactics in Moscow
May 22, 2010
Dear Colleagues,
A few days ago, Arkady Dvorkovich issued a letter to all chess federations admitting that he scheduled the Russian Chess Federation Supervisory Council meeting on May 14th. At that meeting, an open vote occurred with a quorum present electing me as the RCF’s candidate for FIDE President. In the face of the evidence I presented – the original RCF meeting announcement – Mr. Dvorkovich now appears to concede it was always supposed to take place at the Botvinnik Central Chess Club. He and Kirsan Ilyumzhinov previously falsely stated to the press that the meeting was originally scheduled for a different location.
It must be understood that Mr. Dvorkovich’s latest letter is a personal one and does not represent the will of the RCF, which openly voted against him on this issue. In his letter, he presents a new set of phony justifications to challenge the results of an election which took place in full accordance with current regulations. Mr. Dvorkovich virtually accuses himself of failing to register the NGO he was appointed to supervise. Regardless, he well knows that State registration relates only to banking and tax matters, and not the internal activities of the NGO. Moreover, Mr. Dvorkovich has repeatedly pretended to act on behalf of the Russian Chess Federation – the same RCF he now says is an illegitimate organization. It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that he will say anything to attack the election results regardless of consistency or accuracy. My nomination from the RCF is a matter of public record.
Mr. Dvorkovich’s position in the Russian Chess Federation was granted by the Russian Congress, the same Congress that granted Mr. Alexander Bakh his position. The difference between the two positions is that Mr. Bakh, not Mr. Dvorkovich, was assigned the right to sign documents on behalf of the Russian Chess Federation. Accordingly, Mr. Dvorkovich has no authority to act unilaterally on behalf of the Russian Chess Federation. He attempts to place himself above the law and above the elected council members, but his statements carry no power. It is worth noting that following the guidelines of President Medvedev, the Gossoviet of Russia (State Council) recently ordered senior government officials to step down from directing national sports organizations.
It is ironic that Mr. Dvorkovich libels me as pursuing the presidency of FIDE for improper purposes. I was not aware that there is significant money involved in chess at the moment. Perhaps Mr. Dvorkovich can enlighten us all about the financial dealings of FIDE and his involvement.
In attempting to overturn the formal vote of the Supervisory Council, Mr. Dvorkovich has organized a hostile takeover of the Russian Chess Federation. It began with the official website of the Federation and the seizure and of the RCF’s bank accounts. Then on May 20, three men from a private security force took over of the Central Chess Club, expelled Mr. Bakh from his office, and sealed all documents present – all with no court order or other legal justification. They carried only a paper with Mr. Dvorkovich’s signature. While Mr. Ilyumzhinov’s loss in the vote may have been embarrassing to Mr. Dvorkovich, his displeasure does not make the vote “illegitimate” or justify illegal acts by a senior governmental official. Knocking the pieces off the board when you lose does not change the result.
I won an open vote among numerous delegates across Russia and will proudly represent my country as I have for years, with dignity and integrity. I care deeply about our great game of chess, its traditions and its future. My thanks to all of my supporters. I will not let you down.
Several federations have already contacted me to discuss a distinct issue arising from Mr. Dvorkovich’s letter – namely his efforts to intimidate other federations from supporting me. This is of course a profoundly disturbing action by a senior government official in the host country of the upcoming election and will no doubt be the subject of much discussion.
Very Best Regards,
Anatoly Karpov
12th World Chess Champion
REFERENCES
From the press release from the Russian Chess Federation, issued May 16, 2010, detailing the events of the May 14 meeting of the Supervisory Council of the RCF at the Central Chess Club MM Botvinnik (http://www.e3e5.com/newsitem.php?id=13303)
1) The presence of a quorum was recorded. In attendance: Andrei Selivanov (Acting Vice-President of FIDE, honorary president of the Russian Federation, Deputy President of the Supervisory Council), Alexander Bakh (Southern Federal District, Chairman of Executive Board of the Supervisory Council), Kryukov, Beshukov, Ertel (Central Federal District), Afromeev, Titov (Ural Federal District), Gilyazov (Siberian Federal District), Khasin, Zinder, Kazakov (Privolzhsky), Goncharov, Razuvaev (Moscow), Fedorova (Tula), Sapfirov (Krasnodar), Shaidullin (Tomsk), Ivakhin (Severo-West Federal District).
2) Dvorkovich and Zhukov have stated that the May 14 meeting was not legitimate because the new statutes of the RCF have not been registered with the Department of Justice. However, under Russian law the registration of NGOs is required only for the legal entity. Affairs related to the internal organization are decided on the basis of documents adopted by its supreme governing body – in this case, the Council. Proceeding on this basis and given the availability of a quorum, the Supervisory Council began work.
3) The Council approved the draft agenda, which included an item on the nomination of a candidate for FIDE President of the Russian Chess Federation. Forwarding his agenda item were GM Razuvaev, as well as the representatives of the regional federations of Chelyabinsk, Voronezh, Tula, Moscow, and Tatarstan.
4) Anatoly Karpov presented details about his election platform, after which voting took place. 17 out of 17 present members of the Supervisory Council voted for the candidacy of Anatoly Karpov.
5) The Council also unanimously agreed to appoint AV Selivanov as the delegate to represent the RCF at the FIDE Congress in Khanty-Mansiysk in September 2010. The Council also nominated AV Selivanov for the post of FIDE vice-president.
6) In addition, the Council was briefed by representatives of the Organizing Committee of the World Chess Olympiad on the progress of their preparations for the competition. The Council appointed vice-chairman AI Kryukov as director of the Organizing Committee of the Olympiad.
7) The Council discussed preparations for the Russian Olympiad teams.
Translations of Russian news reports from the May 14, 2010 meeting of the Supervisory Council of the Russian Chess Federation by news services whose reporters were in attendance.
ITAR-TASS: Moscow, May 14. The Russian Chess Federation (RCF) nominated ex-world champion Anatoly Karpov to be a candidate for president of the international chess federation (FIDE). This decision was made at a meeting of the Supervisory Board of the RCF.
Gazeta.ru: May14. Twelfth world chess champion Anatoly Karpov was nominated for the presidency of the International Chess Federation (FIDE) by the Russian Chess Federation (RCF) according to the correspondent of Gazeta.ru. The Supervisory Council of the Chess Federation came together on Friday at the chess club on Gogol Boulevard. 18 of 32 [sic, 17] Council members participated to produce a quorum. They unanimously voted for Karpov. Supporters of the nomination of Kirsan Ilyumzhinov, the acting head of FIDE and president of Kalmykia, tried to postpone the meeting and to move it to another location, but their proposal was not accepted.
Kommersant: May 14. At the meeting of the Supervisory Board of the RCF it was decided to nominate 12th world chess champion Anatoly Karpov as a candidate to the post of FIDE president. 17 of the 32 present members of the Council supported the decision. It is worth noting that the current president of FIDE Kirsan Ilyumzhinov and the chairman of the Council, Arkady Dvorkovich, were not present at the meeting.
English
Español
Русский